MLB rumors: Should Phillies add any of top remaining starting pitchers?

Phillies' Starting Pitcher Need: Who Could Help Them?

The Philadelphia Phillies, one of the most storied franchises in Major League Baseball, are looking to bolster their starting pitcher corps. They're after a reliable arm that can help anchor their rotation for the upcoming season.

While the Phillies haven't been directly linked to any of the top remaining free agent starters, there are a few pitchers worth considering. These include lefty Framber Valdez, who has a qualifying offer attached to him and is reportedly seeking upwards of $30 million per year. Zack Gallen, another highly-touted right-hander, also received a qualifying offer, which may make him too pricey for the Phillies.

For the Phillies, it's not about finding a perfect fit but rather someone who can provide stability and depth at an affordable price point. Lucas Giolito, who made $19.3 million last season with the Red Sox, is worth considering after his solid 10-4 record and 3.26 ERA. Chris Bassitt, another seasoned veteran, could also be a viable option if he signs for a reasonable one-year deal.

However, Nick Martinez, a righty with a career 4.16 ERA, may offer the most value at $35 million per year. He's 35 years old but had three stellar seasons before taking a step back in 2025. The Phillies might be able to find a way to make him work without breaking the bank.

Two of the top pitchers who are unlikely to sign with the Phillies include Justin Verlander and Max Scherzer, both of whom will likely pitch into June if they're acquired by another contender. Aaron Civale is also not considered an upgrade over Walker and Zack Littell may be worth a look at $4-8 million.

For the Phillies, it's about having a deep and experienced rotation that can help carry their offense to success. With space to make a move and a history of bargain hunting, they're likely to find a reliable starter who won't break the bank.
 
I think the Phillies would be crazy not to give Lucas Giolito a shot 😊. He's already proven he can bring in 10 wins and has that sweet ERA under 4. If they can get him for less than $25 mil, I'd say it's a steal πŸ€‘. Martinez is old but has been on fire lately, might be worth the risk too πŸ’ͺ. But Verlander and Scherzer? No way, they're gonna cost an arm and a leg πŸ’Έ. The Phillies need someone who can come in and contribute without breaking the bank, that's key for 'em πŸ€‘.
 
idk why ppl r saying martinez is the answer lol hes 35 n hasnt been good in one season πŸ€·β€β™‚οΈ think giolito or bassitt wud b way more sensible tho πŸ’Έ they both got skills n r not as pricey as martinez
 
im think nick martinez could be a great fit for phillies he's had 3 good seasons in a row before taking a step back now at 35 he might not be as expensive as some ppl think $35m per year is still pretty reasonable considering what they got from gallen last yr πŸ€”
 
The Phillies need someone who can keep up with their offense 😊. I think Giolito's last season was solid but I'm not sure he'll want to go back to $19 million per year... Zack Gallen is out of range though, 30 mil a year is steep even for a top arm πŸ€‘. Maybe Martinez at 35 bucks a year is worth the risk, he's been solid before and can't be any worse than Bassitt or Civale...
 
idk why teams still think max scherzer is gonna come back from 1 injury year lol he's like a 40 yr old wrangler trying to herd cats on the mound 🀣 anyway i guess the phillies have some decent options left but nick martinez might be their best shot at not blowing up their whole budget πŸ’Έ lucas giolito is a solid choice too, been there done that with his red sox stint last year πŸ‘€
 
The Phillies need someone with heart, not just stats, you know? 🀝 They've been through tough times in Philly, but that's what makes it special. I think Martinez would be awesome, he's like the underdog of pitchers! πŸ’ͺ The team needs to focus on finding someone who can keep them in games, not just blow them out. It's all about balance and chemistry, trust me, I've seen some teams fall apart when they get too focused on winning at all costs 🀯.
 
omg I'm so hyped for the Phillies this season 🀩! they need someone with some serious clout like Framber Valdez or Zack Gallen, but let's be real, those guys are gonna cost an arm and a leg πŸ’Έ. Lucas Giolito is def worth considering tho, he had a sick season last year 🎯. Nick Martinez too, he's 35 but still got some juice left in him πŸ”₯. I'm not sure about Chris Bassitt though, maybe they can get him for like $5 million or something? πŸ˜‚ and btw, who's gonna take the place of Justin Verlander on this team? πŸ€”
 
The Phillies' pursuit of a starting pitcher is an intriguing development πŸ€”. I think Lucas Giolito could be a shrewd signing for the team – his solid 2024 season and relatively affordable contract ($19.3 million) make him an attractive option at this stage of free agency. On the other hand, Nick Martinez's 35-year-old age might seem like a concern, but three stellar seasons prior to a slight regression in 2025 suggests he still has value πŸ’‘.

The Phillies' emphasis on finding stability and depth at a reasonable price point is wise, considering their history of making savvy moves in the offseason πŸ”. However, it's unclear whether they'll be able to persuade Martinez or other top free agents to join the team without exceeding their budget constraints πŸ€‘.
 
I think the Phillies should consider signing Framber Valdez πŸ€”, he's got that qualifying offer attached to him but I think it's worth it for the stability he can bring to their rotation. And yeah, Zack Gallen is probably too pricey at this point 😐. Lucas Giolito seems like a solid option too, his numbers last season were impressive πŸ“Š. He might be able to fill that one spot they need without breaking the bank πŸ’Έ. Martinez could be a good value pick up, not sure if 35 and getting $35M/year is a no-go though πŸ€¦β€β™‚οΈ. And honestly, who needs Verlander or Scherzer when you can get guys like Civale for less? πŸ˜‰
 
I'm so hyped for the Phillies to sign someone this offseason 🀩! I think Nick Martinez would be an amazing addition, he's still got it at 35 πŸ˜‚. $35 million might seem steep but I think they can make it work. Lucas Giolito is also a solid choice, his ERA last season was insane 🀯. And let's not forget about Chris Bassitt, a vet with experience and a reasonable price tag πŸ’Ό. I know some fans are sad about Zack Gallen not coming, but I think the Phillies can find someone who'll bring just as much heat πŸ”₯. Fingers crossed they can make some magic happen this offseason 🀞
 
I think the Phillies should go for Nick Martinez at $35 million per year πŸ€” he's been having some ups and downs in his career but that price is way too low considering what he can offer on the mound πŸ’ͺ plus they gotta keep Walker and Littell around, don't see Civale being an upgrade tbh 😐 Giolito or Bassitt would be great options too if they sign for a one-year deal πŸ“ˆ the key is finding someone who's gonna provide stability without draining all their cash reserves πŸ’Έ
 
πŸ€” I don't get why Zack Gallen's qualifying offer is making him too pricey for the Phillies... like, what's so special about him that he needs to be paid $40 million+? πŸ€‘ And isn't Lucas Giolito due for a raise after his solid season last year? He seems like a no-brainer at $20 million. πŸ€·β€β™‚οΈ Also, I wonder if the Phillies would be better off targeting some of the younger guys like Littell or Civale... do they think those guys are ready to take on more responsibility in the rotation? 😐
 
The Phillies need someone with experience but not too pricey lol πŸ€·β€β™‚οΈ Framber Valdez is outta my budget tho πŸ’Έ 35 year old Nick Martinez could be a good option tho he's had some decent seasons before kinda dipping in his last year πŸ“‰. Giolito and Bassitt could also work out well, they're not too expensive like Zack Gallen. The Phillies are trying to find someone with stability but it's all about finding that balance between value and price πŸ’Έ
 
I'm telling ya, something fishy is going on with this Phillies' starting pitcher situation 😏. They're not directly linked to any top free agents, but it's like they're trying to keep their options open for some reason. I mean, $30 million per year for Framber Valdez? That's a pretty penny! πŸ€‘ And what's up with Zack Gallen getting a qualifying offer? Is the Phillies' front office just trying to create more competition in the market or something? πŸ€”
 
The Phillies' quest for a new starting pitcher is an intriguing one πŸ€”. On one hand, you have talented arms like Framber Valdez and Zack Gallen, but their price tags might be a bit steep for the Phillies' liking. On the other hand, seasoned veterans like Lucas Giolito and Chris Bassitt could provide stability at a more affordable cost πŸ’Έ. I think Nick Martinez could be the sweet spot here – he's had some stellar seasons in the past, but is now looking for a new home at $35 million per year πŸ€‘. The Phillies' history of bargain hunting bodes well for finding a reliable starter who won't break the bank πŸ“ˆ.
 
πŸ€” I think the Phillies are looking for someone with stability & depth, not just straight up talent... like Lucas Giolito is solid but pricey. Chris Bassitt could be a nice one year deal and Nick Martinez has value at 35 yrs old... Martinez had 3 stellar seasons before taking a step back πŸ“‰
 
Back
Top