New York lawmakers are seizing on the recent federal immigration agent killing in Minneapolis to push for a bill that would restrict state and local police from cooperating with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The proposed legislation, known as the New York for All Act, would block state and local officers from enforcing federal immigration laws and sharing sensitive information with ICE unless there is a judicial warrant. It also ensures that people in custody are informed of their legal rights before being interviewed by immigration agents.
The push comes after a year of heightened Trump administration deportations, which have sparked nationwide protests and demonstrations. New York City already has some of the country's strongest sanctuary laws, but advocates say more needs to be done to protect the rights of immigrants living in the state.
Governor Kathy Hochul is seen as a key player in this effort. While she has walked a fine line on immigration issues, recent events have caused her to publicly denounce ICE's conduct and propose policy changes that would allow New Yorkers to seek recourse if they are injured or their property is damaged by ICE.
Lawmakers say the bill has gained new momentum amid shifting public opinion. A Siena Research poll found that 65% of respondents believe deploying federal immigration officials to round up illegal immigrants had gone too far, while only 54% support Trump's deportation efforts. Democratic lawmakers and advocacy groups are also pushing for additional bills, including guarantees of legal counsel for immigrants facing deportation.
The fate of the bill remains uncertain, with Speaker Carl Heastie saying that he hasn't discussed it with his conference yet but would in the near future. Republicans have strongly opposed any effort to limit local law enforcement's cooperation with ICE, and Assemblymember Jarett Gandolfo has proposed a bill to overrule certain sanctuary policies.
Supporters of the New York for All Act are confident they can get Governor Hochul on board, saying that this is not a time to nitpick but to take bold action to protect immigrant communities.
The push comes after a year of heightened Trump administration deportations, which have sparked nationwide protests and demonstrations. New York City already has some of the country's strongest sanctuary laws, but advocates say more needs to be done to protect the rights of immigrants living in the state.
Governor Kathy Hochul is seen as a key player in this effort. While she has walked a fine line on immigration issues, recent events have caused her to publicly denounce ICE's conduct and propose policy changes that would allow New Yorkers to seek recourse if they are injured or their property is damaged by ICE.
Lawmakers say the bill has gained new momentum amid shifting public opinion. A Siena Research poll found that 65% of respondents believe deploying federal immigration officials to round up illegal immigrants had gone too far, while only 54% support Trump's deportation efforts. Democratic lawmakers and advocacy groups are also pushing for additional bills, including guarantees of legal counsel for immigrants facing deportation.
The fate of the bill remains uncertain, with Speaker Carl Heastie saying that he hasn't discussed it with his conference yet but would in the near future. Republicans have strongly opposed any effort to limit local law enforcement's cooperation with ICE, and Assemblymember Jarett Gandolfo has proposed a bill to overrule certain sanctuary policies.
Supporters of the New York for All Act are confident they can get Governor Hochul on board, saying that this is not a time to nitpick but to take bold action to protect immigrant communities.
! Like, the fact that NYC already has some strong sanctuary laws and now we're talking about expanding those protections even more? 
It's about time, right? I mean, who doesn't want to make sure law enforcement is focusing on actual crimes rather than chasing down immigrants? 
And can you blame people for being upset after what happened in Minneapolis? That was straight outta a horror movie. 
But for real, this bill would be a huge step forward for immigrant rights. It's like, we need to take care of our own people first, you know? 
The fact that Governor Hochul is on board and the momentum is building... yeah, I'm feeling it! 
Let's make this happen! 
. I mean, we already have sanctuary laws in place in NYC, but more isn't always better, you know? We need to find a balance between keeping our communities safe and being kind to people who are just trying to live their lives here 
. I mean, politicians trying to capitalize on a tragic event by pushing their own agendas? It just feels like they're using fear and anxiety for their own gain 
. And what's with the "New York for All Act" name? Sounds like some kinda PR stunt 
. I'm not saying I don't get why people are upset about ICE, but this feels like a classic case of bandwagon jumping 
.
.
... but at the same time, isn't it kinda hard to just block all cooperation with ICE? like, what if some officer sees something that should be reported, but can't because of some new law 
?
... anyway, it'll be nice to see what happens next! 
65% of people think deploying federal immigration officials was too much, that's wild! 
And yeah, it's not just about sanctuary laws, it's about making sure everyone knows their rights and stuff. I feel bad for those who get hurt or have their property damaged by ICE, they deserve some help. 
. It's crazy how the recent ICE agent killing has brought everyone together - even Republicans are starting to see sense 
. Governor Hochul is a total boss for speaking up and proposing changes 
. And can we talk about how New York City already has some of the strongest sanctuary laws? Like, they're setting the bar high 
! The fact that 65% of people believe deploying federal immigration officials went too far is like, super empowering 
️. Let's keep pushing for these bills and make sure everyone knows their rights 
I'm so hyped about this! We need more states like NY taking a stand against ICE's brutal methods. The fact that 65% of ppl think deploying federal immigration officials was way too far is a major wake-up call 
. governor hochul seems like shes tryna do the right thing, but theres still a lot of pushback from republicans 
. Can't we just pass a law that protects immigrants without all the drama and backroom deals? 
. I mean, can't we just treat people with basic human rights and dignity? 
.
It seems like we're just patching holes in a broken system instead of tackling the root problem. Plus, I'm not sure how effective these laws really are - we've seen plenty of instances where "sanctuary cities" still get raided by ICE... it's all about politics, right? 
️. She's showing that she cares about the well-being of all New Yorkers, not just those who are born here 
. And I'm so glad to see the public opinion shifting towards supporting immigrant rights 
. It's like, we're finally having a conversation about what it means to be an American 
.
, but I'm confident that with everyone working together, this bill can make a real difference in people's lives 
. Let's keep those fingers crossed for a yes vote 
. People are starting to realize that sometimes, the things we think we know can be wrong 
The thing is, it's all about perspective 
. We gotta keep having those tough conversations and listening to each other's stories 
. That's how we grow as a society, you know?
. Like, I get it, there was this one incident where an immigration agent got killed in Minneapolis and stuff, but restricting state and local police from cooperating with federal agencies seems like a really broad move 
. Like, Governor Hochul is doing a good job by publicly denouncing ICE's conduct and proposing policy changes that would allow New Yorkers to seek recourse if they're injured or their property gets damaged by ICE 
. And I'm loving that advocates are pushing for more bills to protect immigrants' rights 
. It's not going to be easy, but if the people come out strong enough, maybe we'll see some real change soon 
! It's time for us to take bold action and protect our immigrant communities 