In the scorching streets of climate-ravaged Kolkata, a desperate guardian and a cunning thief navigate the treacherous landscape of scarcity and survival. Megha Majumdar's latest novel, A Guardian and a Thief, is a gripping tale of two characters bound by a complex web of moral ambiguity.
Ma, a young woman who runs a homeless shelter, has been stealing food to feed her family, convinced that she's doing the right thing as a guardian. However, when a new resident discovers her thievery, Ma's world is turned upside down. The thief, Boomba, steals not only the food but also Ma's purse, containing passports and climate visas that will take her family to safety in America.
Majumdar's prose is starkly efficient, eschewing traditional narrative tools like semicolons and wordplay in favor of a lean, third-person voice. This stripped-back style allows her to focus on the moral stakes, ratcheting up tension as Ma's situation becomes increasingly dire. Yet, this efficiency comes at a cost, making the novel feel more like a thriller than a nuanced exploration of climate fiction.
As Kolkata teeters on the brink of famine, Majumdar offers a searing indictment of India's elite and their reluctance to adapt to a world in crisis. The novel shines a light on the hypocrisy of those who claim to care about family but use it as an excuse to exploit others. It also critiques the notion that climate change is a Western problem, instead highlighting the intricate web of class divisions within India.
One area where Majumdar falters is in her handling of climate fiction. The plot twist involving Boomba's ignorance of passports strains credibility, and the novel's reliance on convenient coincidences feels contrived. Moreover, the US government's willingness to issue "climate visas" without sufficient context or explanation rings hollow.
Despite these missteps, A Guardian and a Thief remains a powerful and thought-provoking novel that raises essential questions about moral accountability in the face of climate change. Majumdar's writing is razor-sharp, offering a piercing critique of India's elite and their response to crisis. As the world grapples with the devastating consequences of climate change, this novel serves as a timely reminder that even the most privileged among us must confront our own complicity in the disaster unfolding around us.
Ma, a young woman who runs a homeless shelter, has been stealing food to feed her family, convinced that she's doing the right thing as a guardian. However, when a new resident discovers her thievery, Ma's world is turned upside down. The thief, Boomba, steals not only the food but also Ma's purse, containing passports and climate visas that will take her family to safety in America.
Majumdar's prose is starkly efficient, eschewing traditional narrative tools like semicolons and wordplay in favor of a lean, third-person voice. This stripped-back style allows her to focus on the moral stakes, ratcheting up tension as Ma's situation becomes increasingly dire. Yet, this efficiency comes at a cost, making the novel feel more like a thriller than a nuanced exploration of climate fiction.
As Kolkata teeters on the brink of famine, Majumdar offers a searing indictment of India's elite and their reluctance to adapt to a world in crisis. The novel shines a light on the hypocrisy of those who claim to care about family but use it as an excuse to exploit others. It also critiques the notion that climate change is a Western problem, instead highlighting the intricate web of class divisions within India.
One area where Majumdar falters is in her handling of climate fiction. The plot twist involving Boomba's ignorance of passports strains credibility, and the novel's reliance on convenient coincidences feels contrived. Moreover, the US government's willingness to issue "climate visas" without sufficient context or explanation rings hollow.
Despite these missteps, A Guardian and a Thief remains a powerful and thought-provoking novel that raises essential questions about moral accountability in the face of climate change. Majumdar's writing is razor-sharp, offering a piercing critique of India's elite and their response to crisis. As the world grapples with the devastating consequences of climate change, this novel serves as a timely reminder that even the most privileged among us must confront our own complicity in the disaster unfolding around us.
! It's like, this woman Ma is doing everything she can to survive for her family, but at the same time, she's breaking the law... like, morally speaking. And then there's this other character Boomba who's just a total wild card - I loved how they balanced each other out 
.
. The writing style is so unique, it feels like you're just getting straight to the point without any frills 
. And I love how it highlights all these issues with class divisions and climate change in India - it's like, we need more books like this, you know? 
And the US government's response felt kinda...off. Anyway, it's still a super thought-provoking book that makes you think about where you stand on all this climate change stuff 
.
.
just finished reading about this new novel "A Guardian and a Thief" by Megha Majumdar and I'm still reeling from it... the way she weaves together the moral complexities of survival in a climate-ravaged world is really something 
. And Majumdar isn't afraid to call out the hypocrisy of those in power who claim to care but are actually doing the opposite.
. The whole thing with Boomba's ignorance of passports just felt kinda convenient and didn't add much depth to the story imo 
. And can we talk about how unrealistic that "climate visa" system is? 
. That being said, the themes of class division and moral accountability are SO important, especially in the context of climate change 
A Guardian and a Thief shines a light on the hypocrisy, kudos to Megha Majumdar for not sugarcoating it 
Still, kudos for making me think, Megha Majumdar...now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go enjoy some actual thrills in a Netflix series or something 
.
. And the way she highlights the intricate web of class divisions within India is like, totally on point 
.
. But overall, A Guardian and a Thief is an unflinching and necessary read for anyone who cares about climate justice 
.
! The story's set in this super climate-ravaged Kolkata, where survival is a daily struggle. Ma's character is so complex, doing the right thing but also getting caught up in this morally ambiguous web. I loved how the author kept it simple, minimalistic prose - it really added to the tension and urgency of the plot 
.
. And sometimes the coincidences felt a tad too convenient 
it's super efficient but sometimes feels a bit too lean, like it's missing some depth. still, 10/10 would read more from this author 
. But what really got me was how she portrays these super wealthy people in India who are more worried about their status than helping others during a crisis 
. It's like, they're saying "my family's suffering too" but really they're just using that as an excuse to exploit everyone else 
. But what I love most about this book is that it makes you uncomfortable, forces you to confront your own privilege and complicity in the system 
. And I mean, let's be real, climate change is a global issue, not just some Western problem 
.
i mean, who issues "climate visas" out of thin air? 
and don't even get me started on that plot twist with boomba's ignorance of passports 
it felt like a contrived cop-out to me. but overall, the book still packs some serious punches 
but i gotta say, i did find some parts of it a bit hard to swallow like that plot twist with boomba and passports 
. i love how she strips away all the fancy writing stuff and gets straight to the heart of the matter. its like, you can feel the desperation and hunger and fear in every word.
. still tho, this book is soooo thought-provoking! its like, it makes you wanna question everything about class divisions in india and how we're all complicit in climate change. i need to talk to someone about this ASAP 