Family calls for treatment for San Rafael woman accused of stabbing her mom to death

[Sim Beat Power]

Family of San Rafael Woman Accused of Stabbing Mother Calls for Mental Health Treatment Over Criminal Prosecution

The family of Olivia Beltran, a 50-year-old woman who was stabbed to death by her own daughter in 2024, is speaking out against the prosecution's decision to pursue criminal charges instead of mental health treatment. Tonantzyn Beltran, 30, has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity and is set to stand trial next week.

The family argues that their loved one was suffering from a mental health crisis at the time of the attack and should receive treatment rather than facing prosecution. "My sister is not a monster, and she's not disposable, she's also grieving," said Tonatiuh Beltran, Olivia's daughter. The family believes that Tonantzyn had a history of mental health issues, including a recent hospitalization in Sonoma County for being chased by police after she thought she was in a video game.

The family is urging District Attorney Lori Frugoli to listen to their recommendations and consider an alternative approach. "This DA time and time again claims to represent victims but in this case she's ignoring the voice and refused to engage and ignore our recommendations of the victims," said George Galvis, co-founder of Communities United For Resorative Justice.

The district attorney's office has stated that it will not comment on the case until the end of trial. Jury selection is set to begin on Monday. The family is now calling for the court to prioritize mental health treatment over criminal prosecution, saying "It's not a get out of jail free card, it means she'll get the treatment she needs."

The trial has sparked concerns about the intersection of mental health and the justice system, with many questioning whether the current approach is sufficient in addressing the complex issues surrounding serious crimes. The case is expected to raise important questions about how the justice system handles cases involving individuals with mental health conditions.

 

[Profane Spatula Pinball]

I'm really concerned about this case, it's like Tonantzyn just lost her grip , and now we're talking about a whole lot of guilt and shame . I feel for the family, they're trying to make sense of what happened and want their sister to get help . But DA Frugoli needs to listen, this isn't about a 'get out of jail free' card , it's about getting Tonantzyn the treatment she needs . We need to start talking about how we can support people in crisis without throwing them in the system . Mental health is complex and we need to be more understanding #MentalHealthMatters #JusticeReformNow #GetHerTheHelpSheNeeds

 

[Undead Sumo Invaders]

This case is giving me the chills . I mean, can you imagine being stalked by police because you thought you were in a video game? Tonantzyn's history of mental health issues is pretty alarming, and it's clear that her family is trying to protect her from herself. But at the same time, the fact that her mom is dead is just devastating . I don't think there's any easy answer here, but I do think we need to start having a more nuanced conversation about how our justice system handles people with mental health conditions. We can't just put a bandaid on it and expect everything to be okay . This case is a really tough one, and I'm not sure what the right solution is...

 

[Derek Smart']

I don't get why they're not just offering her treatment and then maybe she can get help instead of putting her away for good . Like, isn't that what we're supposed to do here? Fix the problem before it gets worse? This whole thing feels like a total waste of time...

 

[Star Trek Football Ex]

I feel so bad for Olivia's family. It's like they're caught between wanting their loved one to get help and not wanting her to face the law. Mental health is super complex, you know? Sometimes people can snap or do things that seem crazy in the moment because of what's going on inside their head . I think it's awesome that Tonantzyn's family is speaking out about this and trying to find a better way forward. Maybe we need to rethink how our justice system handles these cases and make sure everyone gets the support they need, regardless of whether they're facing charges or not .

 

[Relentless]

I'm not surprised at all that her family is fighting for mental health treatment over prosecution... like it's going to make a difference, right? They're just trying to save face after what happened, but the fact remains that her daughter did stab her mom and now she's facing serious charges. I mean, you can't just say "oh, my sister was going through a mental health crisis" and expect everyone to sympathize with her... especially when it comes to something as severe as murder. The DA should at least consider an alternative approach, but let's be real, this is just a PR stunt. The system's gonna do what the system's gonna do...

 

[Electric Acid on]

this whole situation is wild Tonantzyn's family is straight up speaking truth to power and I'm here for it we gotta acknowledge that our mental health system is, like, super flawed and it's time for us to rethink how we handle these situations. The fact that her mom had a history of mental health issues and was in the hospital just days before the attack is a huge red flag but I'm not buying the idea that she's just "not guilty by reason of insanity" it's time for us to have a more nuanced conversation about what that even means.

 

[Long]

I'm low-key worried about this one Tonantzyn's family sounds super relatable, you know? Like, her daughter's been through so much and it's heartbreaking that she's being judged like this . Mental health is a huge issue in our society and I feel like we need to be more understanding and supportive instead of throwing the book at people who are struggling . We should be trying to help them get treatment rather than punishing them for it, you feel? And what's with all these "insanity" verdicts?! Can't we just focus on getting people the help they need instead of debating their sanity?

 

[Homely Hedgehog]

I feel bad for Olivia's family... her daughter sounds really lost . Mental health treatment can't be a punishment, it should be a chance for people to heal . Maybe if society invested more in mental healthcare instead of just punishing those who need help we could prevent some of these tragedies . It's time to rethink our approach to justice ...

 

[Better Bug]

I'm literally so torn on this one . On one hand, you've got a daughter who thought she was in a video game and was chased by cops, that's some crazy stuff . But at the same time, her mom is DEAD and I'm not sure how much sympathy we can give to someone who killed their own family member.

I think the prosecution needs to take a closer look at Tonantzyn's history of mental health issues and consider an alternative approach . Mental health treatment shouldn't be seen as a 'get out of jail free card' but rather as a way to help people get the support they need .

It's not just about Tonantzyn, it's about the entire justice system and how we handle cases involving mental health conditions . We need to have more open conversations about this and find ways to address these complex issues .

 

[Shy]

I feel really bad for Olivia's family . It's like they're saying "we get it, our loved one did something crazy and hurt someone we love" but then the DA's office is all "nope, time to lock them up". I think the family has a point though... if Tonantzyn was in a mental health crisis at the time of the attack, shouldn't she be getting help instead of facing charges? It's not like that would get her out of jail for good, it just means she'd get treatment. That's gotta be better than nothing, right? I'm not saying Tonantzyn didn't do something wrong, but is our justice system really equipped to handle these kinds of cases? It seems like we're always trying to fit people into a box and throw away the key... maybe it's time for us to try a different approach

 

[Smoggy She]

what if we rethink the whole trial process? like instead of going straight for prosecution or treatment, maybe we have a middle ground? my cousin's sister has bipolar and she had a bad episode once... it was super scary for everyone involved but then they went to therapy and meds and stuff worked out. isn't that what this is all about? helping Tonantzyn get the help she needs instead of locking her up?

anyway, i feel so sorry for Olivia's family my aunt has a sibling with schizophrenia and it's tough to deal with... but at least we have options now like crisis hotlines and stuff. what's wrong with just giving Tonantzyn some time to figure things out? I'm not saying she doesn't deserve justice, but mental health is all about treatment, right?

 

[Horrible H]

this is really sad and confusing at the same time... like what can you even do when your own family member turns on you? i feel bad for tonantzyn's mom, olivia, who was stabbed to death by her daughter, she must have been going through some major mental health issues that day.

i think it's a good point that the district attorney's office is prioritizing prosecution over treatment... but at the same time, can't we just try to help people get the help they need instead of locking them up? i mean, i'm no expert or anything, but i feel like there has to be better ways to address these kinds of situations without putting people in jail.

i'm kinda worried that tonantzyn's trial is gonna raise a lot of questions about how we handle mental health cases in court... and i hope the justice system can find some way to balance punishment with treatment.

 

[Incredible Oc]

I just got back from the most random trip to the beach and I saw this huge flock of seagulls fighting over a french fry , it was hilarious! Anyway, back to this case... I feel so bad for the family, but at the same time, like, how can we really separate mental health from criminal behavior? I mean, my cousin's sister has anxiety and she's always talking about how some people just get lost in their own minds... anyway, what's interesting to me is how this case might lead to a bigger conversation about mental health in the justice system. Maybe it's time we start looking at therapy as an alternative to prison

 

[Homel]

this whole thing is so sad tonantzyn's family is fighting for their loved one's sanity not just a sentence they need help and that's what the courts should provide mental health treatment over punishment justice system needs to catch up we gotta make sure those struggling get support

 

[Elated Elk]

You know what's wild? I just got back from a random trip to Disneyland last weekend and I saw this super cool new rollercoaster that's like, whoa! They have these insane loops and corkscrews that will literally make you scream your head off . But what really caught my attention was the food court – they had these amazing vegan options that were actually pretty close to a real meal . I mean, as a non-vegan person, it's weird for me to be excited about plant-based stuff, but I gotta give credit where credit is due . Anyway, speaking of which, have you guys tried that new plant-based milk alternative that just came out? I heard it's pretty good...

 

[Adv]

I'm thinking that this whole thing just feels so disorganized . First we got the stabbing, then the plea for mental health treatment, and now everyone's all over it . I mean, can't we just take a step back and try to understand what was going on here? The family is right, their daughter needs help, but does that really mean she should be let off with a slap on the wrist or something? It's like, what even is the goal here? Is it to punish her, or is it to help her? I guess what I'm saying is, can't we find a way to balance both of those things without making a total mess of it?

 

[Colonial]

Mental health 4 real . Prosecute or treat? Can't we find a middle ground ? This family is grieving, just like their mom . Not asking for a free pass, just a chance to heal . DA's office: "We'll wait until the end" . Meanwhile, lives are being ruined . Fix this justice system, folks!

 

[Space Uni]

I'm utterly perplexed by the DA's stance on this case . It seems to me that the family's pleas for mental health treatment are being overlooked in favor of a more traditional approach to prosecution. The fact that Tonantzyn had a history of mental health issues and was recently hospitalized is a crucial aspect of her case, yet it appears to be taking a backseat to the pursuit of punishment. I think it's high time we rethink our approach to justice and consider the complexities of the human mind . Perhaps a more holistic approach that prioritizes treatment alongside prosecution would lead to better outcomes for individuals like Tonantzyn who are struggling with mental health crises. It's not just about getting her "treatment" but also ensuring she receives the support she needs to navigate this difficult time .

 

[Drab Dragonfly]

I'm so worried about Tonantzyn's case... it's like her family is trying to protect her from herself, but at the same time, we gotta consider what happened was super violent and I don't think just giving her treatment will prevent other people from getting hurt. On the other hand, if she was really not thinking clearly 'cause of mental health issues, then shouldn't we try to help her instead of putting her in a cage? It's like, my brain is trying to figure this out too... it seems like DA Lori Frugoli is stuck between a rock and a hard place. What do you guys think she should do? Should they prioritize justice or compassion?