The $500 billion beauty industry’s ‘green’ ambitions are a patchwork at best. And they’re falling short | CNN

The world's $500 billion beauty industry has set ambitious sustainability goals, but critics say these efforts are "a patchwork at best" that falls short of making a significant impact on the environment.

According to a recent study by Strategy and Consulting firm Simon Kucher, 60% of consumers worldwide view sustainability as an important purchase criterion, with 35% willing to pay more for sustainable products. However, many beauty brands are struggling to meet these expectations, with inconsistent efforts to reduce single-use plastics, improve recyclable packaging, and provide transparency around ingredients.

One major challenge is the lack of international standardization in the industry. Brands can set their own sustainability goals, leading to "greenwashing" where companies make unsubstantiated claims about their products being eco-friendly. Experts say that certifications like B Corp are beneficial but currently voluntary for brands to apply for.

Governments and multinationals could play a crucial role in regulating the industry, setting minimum requirements for sustainability claims and enforcing stricter waste management laws. However, some experts believe that market leadership will be key in driving change.

Retailers also have a significant impact on the industry's sustainability performance. While Sephora and Target have launched initiatives to promote cleaner packaging, many steps taken by brands and retailers do not address the broader issue of supply chain waste and pollution.

A critical gap is the lack of standardization in ingredient labeling, with varying regulations across countries. For example, the European Chemicals Agency has banned over 2,400 substances from use in cosmetic products marketed for sale or use in the EU bloc, but only 11 such substances have been listed by the US Food and Drug Administration.

The industry's plastic packaging is also a major concern, with an estimated 95% of packaging thrown away and very little recycled. Many brands are trying to phase out single-use plastics and adopt post-consumer recycled (PCR) plastic, but supply issues and high costs pose significant challenges.

Ultimately, it will likely take continued collective advocacy and initiative from consumers, brands, and retailers to drive meaningful climate-conscious change in the beauty industry. As one expert said, "Regulation can raise the floor a bit, but market leadership is key."
 
I'm not sure if the beauty industry's sustainability goals are just a drop in the ocean or a desperate attempt to stay afloat. I mean, think about it - 60% of consumers care about sustainability, but what does that really say? Are they making conscious choices or are they just feeling guilty for buying a face mask? 💄 And let's be real, "greenwashing" is still a thing, and if brands can't even be trusted to tell the truth about their products, how can we trust them to do better?

I guess what I'm saying is that it's all about perspective. Is sustainability just a marketing ploy or is it genuinely making a difference? And honestly, I think we need more than just certifications and voluntary efforts - we need real change, like regulation and education. But at the same time, market leadership can be powerful, especially if consumers are demanding better. It's all about finding that balance and creating a system that rewards sustainable practices, not just green branding 🤔.
 
The beauty industry's eco-friendly claims are kinda sketchy right now 🤔... I mean, 60% of people care about sustainability, which is awesome, but it seems like some brands just slap on a few recyclable packaging elements and call it a day 📦. And don't even get me started on the supply chain waste thing - it's all well and good for Sephora and Target to have their own initiatives, but what about the rest of us? 💸 We need more standardization in ingredient labeling and regulation to make sure companies aren't just greenwashing 🚮.
 
I feel like the beauty industry is trying its best with these new sustainability goals 🤞, but we need more consistency from brands and retailers. I mean, 60% of consumers care about this stuff, so it's not like no one wants eco-friendly options 💚. The problem is, some companies just throw around "eco-friendly" labels without actually doing anything behind the scenes 📦. We need more transparency and standardization in ingredients labeling and packaging. It's also crazy how much plastic waste we're dealing with - 95% of packaging goes straight to the trash?! 😱. I guess what's needed is a combination of government regulation and market pressure to get this industry moving in the right direction 🔄.
 
its like theyre just patching up the problem instead of really tackling it 😒 the whole industry is still riddled with single-use plastics and no real standardization in ingredients 🚮 and europe is literally way ahead of us on this stuff 💔 95% of packaging thrown away is just insane and its all about the supply chain waste pollution 🌪️ some brands are trying to do good but its not enough 🤷‍♀️ market leadership will be key i guess but until then were stuck in this cycle of "oh im buying eco friendly products" only to find out theyre still harming the planet 😒
 
🌎💄 The beauty industry needs to step up its game ⏱️! Sustainability goals are just the start 💪. Brands need to be more transparent about ingredients 🤔 and supply chains 📦. Single-use plastics are a major no-go 🚫. Retailers and governments can help by setting standards 📊 and regulations 🚫. But ultimately, it's all about market leadership and consumer pressure 💬. We need to keep pushing for change 🔄 and hold brands accountable 🔒. It's time for the beauty industry to go green 🌿!
 
I'm like 70% sure that the beauty industry needs to step up its game when it comes to sustainability 🤦‍♀️. I mean, with 60% of consumers caring about eco-friendliness in their purchases, brands should be making more of an effort to reduce waste and pollution 💸. But at the same time, I'm also thinking that governments and multinationals can't just sit back and do nothing - they need to set some minimum standards for sustainability claims and enforce better waste management laws 📊.

And retailers like Sephora and Target are doing a good job by launching initiatives to promote cleaner packaging, but we need more of these kinds of efforts across the board 💪. The supply chain issue is a big one too - it's not just about individual brands making changes, it needs to be a whole industry shift 🔄.

I'm also kinda frustrated that there's still no standardization in ingredient labeling - it's like, how can we trust what we're putting on our skin if we don't know what's really in it? 🤔
 
I think the beauty industry's sustainability goals are kinda half-baked 🤔🌎. They're trying, but it's all over the place. Like, Sephora is super on top of recycling and stuff, but then you got brands that are just using eco-friendly labels as a marketing gimmick 💁‍♀️. And don't even get me started on ingredient labeling - it's like they expect us to magically know what's in our skincare products 🤯. The industry needs some serious standardization and regulation ASAP ⏰. But hey, at least we're talking about it, right? 💬
 
I think people are being pretty harsh on the industry 🤔. I mean, 60% of consumers actually care about sustainability, which is still a significant chunk of people 👍. And yeah, some brands might be doing more than others, but that's kinda like saying someone's outfit is "just okay" 😐.

I think market leadership can make a big difference, but it's not just about individual companies, it's also about what governments and regulations can do 📊. But let's not forget that consumers have the power to choose where they shop and what products they buy 💸. If we all demand more from brands, we can actually drive change 💪.

And honestly, I don't think "greenwashing" is a big enough problem for most people to care about 🤷‍♀️. Like, if someone's using eco-friendly packaging but still making a bunch of waste somewhere else, that's not really sustainable at all 🌎. We need to be looking at the whole supply chain and making sure we're reducing our impact everywhere 💧.
 
🤔 I gotta say, its pretty frustrating when you see companies making half-hearted efforts towards sustainability. Like, 60% of consumers care about eco-friendliness, and brands are still slapping those cute little recyclable packaging stickers on their products? Come on! 📦 It's not enough just to make a few token changes - we need real action here.

And don't even get me started on the lack of standardization. I mean, what even is greenwashing anymore? Brands can just slap a B Corp logo on their website and call it a day. Where's the transparency? 🤷‍♀️ We need more consistent reporting and stricter regulations to make sure companies are actually doing something meaningful.

And retail? They're basically just winging it too. Sephora and Target are trying, but they're not even addressing the bigger issue of supply chain waste. It's time for some real leadership in this industry... 💪
 
Ugh, gotta say I'm super skeptical about these sustainability goals 🤔. It's all just PR at this point, right? 60% of consumers think sustainability matters, but only a tiny fraction are actually willing to pay more for it... meanwhile, the big players are just slapping some eco-friendly labels on their products and calling it a day 📦. And don't even get me started on "greenwashing" - I mean, come on, who needs more of that? The whole industry is so slow to change, and it's all about market leadership, huh? Like, when will we see some real action instead of just lip service? 🙄
 
I'm low-key disappointed that more brands aren't stepping up their game when it comes to sustainability 🤔. I mean, 60% of consumers care about eco-friendliness, but it feels like some are just checking boxes instead of making real changes 💸. The lack of international standardization is a major issue - it's like, can't we all just agree on what "green" means here? 🌿

And don't even get me started on the plastic packaging 🚮. I know some brands are trying to switch to PCR plastic and all that, but it's not easy, and supply chains can be a major bottleneck 💔.

I think we need more than just certifications and regulations to drive change - we need actual leadership and accountability from companies 🤝. And retailers gotta step up their game too, 'cause those are the ones controlling what gets on our shelves 🛍️.

It's gonna take some serious collective effort to make a dent in climate-consciousness in the beauty industry 🔥. But hey, at least we're talking about it now, right? 💬
 
Ugh, I'm literally dying over here thinking about all the plastic waste from the beauty industry 🤯🌎. I mean, 95% of packaging thrown away and only like, 5% recycled? That's crazy! As a student who's always learning about sustainability in school, it's so frustrating to see an industry that's supposed to be "green" is actually contributing so much to the problem 🤦‍♀️.

I think one thing that would really make a difference is if brands and retailers started being more transparent about their ingredients and packaging. Like, who knows what's really in our makeup and skincare products? 😱 And it's not just about recycling and reducing waste, but also about making sure the production process isn't harming people or the environment.

I love that some experts are saying market leadership is key to driving change, though 🤑. If Sephora and Target can set an example and make sustainable choices, maybe other brands will follow suit. And yeah, governments and multinationals could help regulate the industry too 👊.

But honestly, as a student, I think what's most needed right now is education 📚. We need to teach more people about sustainability, especially in school! It's not just about science and math; it's also about understanding the impact of our choices on the planet 🌿💚.
 
idk why ppl care about the environment so much anymore 🤷‍♀️ i mean dont get me wrong beauty products r cool n all, but like what's the big deal bout plastic packaging? cant we just use reusable bags or water bottles? 📦💧 i also wonder how they're gonna regulate it tho, thats a whole thing in itself. i feel like its easier to just buy sustainable stuff if the price is right lol 😂
 
I'm still trying to wrap my head around this $500 billion beauty industry 🤯... like how they're gonna tackle sustainability on such a huge scale? I think it's crazy that 60% of consumers care about eco-friendliness when shopping for beauty products, but brands are just not doing enough. It's so frustrating when you see "greenwashing" happening left and right 😒. I mean, who has the time to fact-check every claim made by a brand?

I think governments and retailers need to step up their game. Like, what's the point of having regulations if no one's gonna enforce them? 🤔 And don't even get me started on supply chain waste... it's like, come on guys! We can do better than this. I just hope consumers keep pushing for change and brands start taking responsibility for their actions 💪. Maybe then we'll see some real progress in the beauty industry.
 
I'm low-key disappointed with how some big beauty brands are tackling sustainability 🤔. I mean, we're talking about $500 billion industry here and they're still using way too much single-use plastics 💦. And don't even get me started on the labeling thing - it's like they're speaking different languages or something 📚. I think governments and multinationals need to step up their game and create some real standards for sustainability claims. But at the same time, I'm keeping an eye on the brands that are really pushing for change 💪. Sephora and Target are doing some cool things with cleaner packaging, but we need more consistency across the board 🤝. It's all about creating a culture of transparency and accountability in this industry... or else 😬.
 
I'm so tired of all these big companies just slapping some eco-friendly labels on their products and calling it a day 🤯! I mean, don't get me wrong, I love a good cruelty-free shampoo as much as the next person, but when you've got brands that are literally using the same old plastic packaging they always have been, it's just misleading.

And can we talk about supply chain waste and pollution for a sec? 🤦‍♀️ Like, if big retailers like Sephora and Target are launching initiatives to promote cleaner packaging, where's the rest of the industry at? It feels like we're getting played into this whole "greenwashing" thing and it's just so frustrating.

I think what we need is some real standardization in ingredient labeling - it's crazy that there are so many different regulations across countries. And can we please get some stricter waste management laws for those single-use plastics? 🚮 It's like, the more we try to "sustain" ourselves, the more we're polluting our own planet. We need to be honest with ourselves about how much of an impact we're having and actually take action on it.

Until then, I'll just keep on supporting those smaller brands that are making real changes 🙏💚
 
Back
Top