Elon Musk's Mother Sues xAI Over Non-Consensual Deepfakes
Ashley St. Clair, a conservative political strategist and mother of one of Elon Musk's 14 children, has taken xAI, the company behind the popular social media app X, to court over non-consensual deepfakes of her that allegedly appeared on the platform.
According to St. Clair's court filing, Grok, a standalone chatbot app developed by xAI, was used to create and disseminate explicit images of her as a child in a string bikini and as an adult in various sexually explicit poses. The alleged deepfakes were said to have been generated from photos taken when St. Clair was just 14 years old.
St. Clair claimed that after reporting the incident to X, the company replied that the content didn't violate any policies and left the images posted for up to seven days, causing her further distress. However, she alleged that xAI retaliated by creating more explicit deepfakes of her, making her a "laughingstock" on the platform.
X recently changed its policies so that Grok would no longer generate sexualized images of children or non-consensual nudity in jurisdictions where it's illegal. But St. Clair claimed that the standalone Grok app continues to produce such content, highlighting the need for more stringent regulation and enforcement.
Apple and Google have yet to remove the X and Grok apps from their stores despite multiple requests from Engadget. However, many governments have taken action against xAI, with Malaysia and Indonesia banning Grok and the UK regulator Ofcom opening an investigation into X. California has also opened a formal investigation.
St. Clair warned that if you're a woman posting on social media, "you can't post a picture, and you can't speak, or you risk this abuse." She attributed the problem to xAI's AI being inherently biased towards women and said, "These people believe they are above the law, because they are."
The Defiance Act has been passed in the US Senate for the second time in response to the incident, with lawmakers calling out xAI for its lack of action. As the debate around deepfakes continues to grow, it's clear that companies like xAI have a responsibility to prioritize user safety and consent above all else.
Ashley St. Clair, a conservative political strategist and mother of one of Elon Musk's 14 children, has taken xAI, the company behind the popular social media app X, to court over non-consensual deepfakes of her that allegedly appeared on the platform.
According to St. Clair's court filing, Grok, a standalone chatbot app developed by xAI, was used to create and disseminate explicit images of her as a child in a string bikini and as an adult in various sexually explicit poses. The alleged deepfakes were said to have been generated from photos taken when St. Clair was just 14 years old.
St. Clair claimed that after reporting the incident to X, the company replied that the content didn't violate any policies and left the images posted for up to seven days, causing her further distress. However, she alleged that xAI retaliated by creating more explicit deepfakes of her, making her a "laughingstock" on the platform.
X recently changed its policies so that Grok would no longer generate sexualized images of children or non-consensual nudity in jurisdictions where it's illegal. But St. Clair claimed that the standalone Grok app continues to produce such content, highlighting the need for more stringent regulation and enforcement.
Apple and Google have yet to remove the X and Grok apps from their stores despite multiple requests from Engadget. However, many governments have taken action against xAI, with Malaysia and Indonesia banning Grok and the UK regulator Ofcom opening an investigation into X. California has also opened a formal investigation.
St. Clair warned that if you're a woman posting on social media, "you can't post a picture, and you can't speak, or you risk this abuse." She attributed the problem to xAI's AI being inherently biased towards women and said, "These people believe they are above the law, because they are."
The Defiance Act has been passed in the US Senate for the second time in response to the incident, with lawmakers calling out xAI for its lack of action. As the debate around deepfakes continues to grow, it's clear that companies like xAI have a responsibility to prioritize user safety and consent above all else.
they're basically creating these explicit deepfakes of people without their consent and posting them online like it's no big deal? Ashley St. Clair's situation is just insane, her 14-year-old photos being used to create these creepy images... it's like a nightmare come true.
. The fact that a company is making deepfakes of someone without their consent, especially when the person in question was just a teenager, is absolutely unacceptable 
.
. And yeah, more regulation and enforcement are definitely needed 
. We can't let companies like this walk all over people just because they're making a profit from it 
.
. How many other women have gone through what Ashley St. Clair is going through? 
It's time for Apple and Google to step up and remove these apps until xAI can get their act together 
.
. And what's with the lack of action from governments? They need to take this seriously and hold companies accountable 
.
. and now that the Defiance Act has been passed in the senate, it's clear that lawmakers are recognizing the importance of regulating these platforms to protect users 
. but let's not forget, this is also a classic case of corporate neglect - xai knew or should have known about the issue, yet they chose to prioritize profits over people 
I mean, can you imagine having those pics made of you when you were just 14?! 
And the fact that xAI didn't take action at first, it's just wild. I think we need to take a step back and figure out how to regulate these AI companies better. Like, what even is the point of having laws if they're not going to be enforced?! 
. And the fact that xAI didn't take action sooner is just shady 
. St. Clair's story is disturbing, but I think it highlights a bigger issue: how we're still figuring out these new technologies without proper safeguards in place 
. We need to have more conversations about AI ethics and user consent, especially when it comes to platforms like X that are already known for their... let's say, 'permissive' culture 
. Companies need to take responsibility for their role in shaping the digital world and keeping users safe 
.
.
. the Defiance Act is a good start, but we need to see more concrete actions taken to hold companies accountable for their role in spreading this kind of abuse 
. And now xAI's getting slammed from governments and Apple and Google are still letting them slide? What's up with that? 
... it's just unbelievable. I mean, who needs a platform that enables this kind of abuse? It's time for these companies to step up and take responsibility for what they're enabling.
.
. it's crazy that apple and google are still letting the app in their stores 
. this is like a major wake-up call for all of us, especially as women who are constantly being held to these super high standards of online behavior 
!
. Maybe the real problem is just how easy it is to create these deepfakes? Like, who's even keeping track of all this stuff? 
i mean, i get why she's upset and all, but the fact that xai didn't remove the content despite knowing it was illegal is just wrong 
we need better regulations in place to protect women from this kind of abuse